Women’s Health: March/April 2022

Older Women on Hormone Replacement Therapy Are HALF as Likely to Die From COVID Than Their Peers, Study Suggests

Luke Andrews and Emily Craig

Feb. 14, 2022 (dailymail.co.uk) — Older women on hormone replacement therapy (HRT) are significantly less likely to get severe Covid, a study suggests.

Women have consistently had a lower death rate than men throughout the pandemic, with high levels of the female hormone estrogen thought to be playing a role.

Swedish scientists monitored 2,500 women in their 60s on HRT — most of them menopausal — who tested positive for Covid during the first wave.

They were compared to 12,000 women of the same age who were not on treatment and 200 cancer survivors using estrogen-blockers.

Results showed that compared to the group not taking estrogen, women on HRT were half as likely to die from the virus, while those on the estrogen-blockers faced double the risk.

Experts said estrogen may protect against Covid because it boosts immunity, helping the body to fight off the virus.

But other scientists warned the study was observational and does not account for a host of other variables like lifestyle, diet and weight.

Both men and women produce estrogen, but women have much higher levels of this hormone than men because it is involved in the menstrual cycle.

When a woman hits the menopause — however — its levels start to drop, triggering hot flushes, night sweats and other symptoms.

Women can take HRT to alleviate these symptoms. It works by replacing estrogen that are at a lower level due to the menopause.

The study, published in the British Medical Journal (BMJ), followed patients who were admitted to hospital between February and September 2020, during the first wave.

Data was extracted from Swedish national databases.

Of the women who were on estrogen-boosting HRT, a total of 54 (2.1 per cent) died from the virus.

But among those receiving no treatment, 546 (4.6 per cent) died from the infection.

And of the women taking estrogen-blockers 23 (10 per cent) died after testing positive.’

The scientist said women on HRT also had a lower fatality rate than others when the results were adjusted for income and education.

Professor Malin Sund at Umeå University in Sweden said: ‘This study shows an association between estrogen levels and Covid death.

‘Consequently, drugs increasing estrogen levels may have a role in therapeutic efforts to alleviate Covid severity in postmenopausal women and could be studied in randomised control trials.’

In the paper, the researchers said estrogen may also help protect women by limiting places the virus can enter cells.

Human cells exposed to high levels of estrogen have fewer ACE2 receptors, a key entry point used by the virus, than those exposed to testosterone.

Professor Stephen Evans, an epidemiologist at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine who was not involved in the research, said the findings were ‘apparently dramatic’.

But, he added: ‘It must be remembered that there is a long history of observational studies, especially in relation to hormone therapy, making dramatic claims of benefit that have not been confirmed in randomised trials.

‘It is quite likely that this study follows in such a line, and at the very least, great caution should be exercised in thinking that menopausal therapy will have substantial, or even any, benefits in dealing with Covid.’

A wealth of studies suggests men are more likely to die from Covid than women.

One paper from the Office for National Statistics found a slightly higher risk, but separate studies from earlier in the pandemic said they could be twice as likely.

The reasons for the gender divide are not clear, but a whole host of other factors including men being more likely to have underlying conditions and avoid seeing the doctors have been suggested.

In England, 77,032 men have died within 28 days of testing positive for Covid, compared to 61,978 women.

 

Copyright © 2022. Published by Associated Newspapers Ltd, Part of the Daily Mail, The Mail on Sunday & Metro Media Group
0